makiawelizm

makiawelizm, studia

[ Pobierz całość w formacie PDF ]
.RQVHUZDW\]P
SO
.OXE
=DFKRZDZF]R
0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\
3UR
ILGH
5HJH
HW
/HJH
6WURQD
]
:ÆDG]H
.OXEX
0$.,$:(/,=0
’RNXPHQW\
+LVWRULD
.OXEX
-DFHN
%DUW\]HO
0$.,$:(/,=0
ZÆ
PDFKLDYHOOLVPR
R
Z
]QDF]HQLX
FLVÆ\P
P\
O
SROLW\F]QD
1LFFROR
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
RUD]
SRNUHZQ\FK
PX
OXE
QDZL
]XM
F\FK
GR
QLHJR
DXWRUyZ
]D]Z\F]DM
QD]\ZDM
F\FK
VLHELH
OXE
QD]\ZDQ\FK
?
SROLW\F]Q\PL
UHDOLVWDPL?
NWyUHM
LVWRW
MHVW
SRMPRZDQLH
SROLW\NL
SU]H]
SU\]PDW
VNXWHF]QR
FL
UR]XPLDQHM
MDNR
NRQLHF]QR
ü
QHFHVVLWD
QLHRG]RZQD
GOD
]DFKRZDQLD
SD
VWZD
RUD]
NLHURZDQLH
VL
UDFM
VWDQX
SU]\
]DÆR*HQLX
QLHXFKURQQR
FL
VWRVRZDQLD
URGNyZ
PRUDOQLH
QDJDQQ\FK
R
Z
]QDF]HQLX
SRWRF]Q\P
V\QRQLP
SROLW\F]QHM
QLHPRUDOQR
FL
KLSRNU\]ML
L
ZLDURÆRPVWZD
ZJ
VÆRZQLNRZHM
GHILQLFML
/DURXVVHCD
?
SRVW
SRZDQLH
QLHORMDOQH
L
SHUILGQH?
FRQGXLW
GpOR\DOH
HW
SHUILGH
0
\
O
S
R
O
L
W
\
F
]
Q
D
0
D
F
K
L
D
Y
H
O
O
H
J
R
0DFKLDYHOOL
E\Æ
SLHUZV]\P
Z
KLVWRULL
P\
OLFLHOHP
NWyU\
QDGDÆ
QRZRF]HVQ\
L
G]L
RELHJRZ\
VHQV
SRM
FLX
?
U
H
S
X
E
O
L
N
D?
NWyUH
GRW
G
E\ÆR
QD]Z
URG]DMRZ
R]QDF]DM
F
SD
VWZR
SUDZRU]
GQH
E
G
FH
?
U]HF]
ZVSyOQ
?
UHV
SXEOLFD
EH]
Z]JO
GX
QD
IRUP
XVWURMRZ
RGW
G
]D
VWDÆR
VL
QD]Z
JDWXQNRZ
R]QDF]DM
F
Z\Æ
F]QLH
QLHPRQDUFKLF]Q\
W\S
XVWURMX
R
WHM
]PLDQLH
SU]HV
G]LÆ
RQ
MX*
Z
SLHUZV]\P
]GDQLX
UR]G]LDÆX
,
.VL
FLD
VWZLHUG]DM
F
:V]HONLH
SD
VWZD
ZV]HONLH
U]
G\
NWyUH
PLDÆ\
OXE
PDM
ZÆDG]
QDG
OXG(PL
E\ZDM
UHSXEOLNDPL
DOER
NVL
VWZDPL?
-HGQRF]H
QLH
Z
W\P
VDP\P
UR]G]LDOH
0DFKLDYHOOL
ZSURZDG]LÆ
LQQH
]QDF]
FH
UR]Uy*QLHQLH
SRPL
G]\
?
NVL
VWZDPL
G]LHG]LF]Q\PL?
D
NVL
VWZDPL
?
QRZ\PL?
XMDZQLD
RQR
D
]DUD]HP
JRG]L
SR]RUQ
VSU]HF]QR
ü
SRJO
GyZ
DXWRUD
DQW\WUDG\FMRQDOLVW\F]Q\
L
DQW\OHJLW\PLVW\F]Q\
VW\O
MHJR
P\
OHQLD
GOD
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
MHVW
U]HF]
RERM
WQ
SUDZRZLWR
ü
ZÆDG]\
]DUyZQR
Z
VHQVLH
OHJLW\PL]PX
SRFKRG]HQLD
G]LHG]LF]HQLD
ZJ
XVWDORQ\FK
]DVDG
VXNFHVML
OXE
RE\F]DMX
MDN
OHJLW\PL]PX
FHOX
RGQRV]HQLD
ZÆDG]\
GR
%RJD
L
-HJR
SUDZD
=
SU]HNRQD
0DFKLDYHOOL
E\Æ
UHSXEOLNDQLQHP
QDZHW
GR
ü
MDN
QD
?
]LPQHJR
UHDOLVW
?
HJ]DOWRZDQ\P
QLH
SU]HV]NDG]DÆR
PX
WR
MHGQDN
ZL
]D
ü
VZRLFK
QDG]LHL
SROLW\F]Q\FK
]
?
NVL
VWZHP?
RUD]
DGUHVRZD
ü
LFK
GR
?
NVL
FLD?
ZÆD
QLH
G]L
NL
RERM
WQR
FL
QD
NZHVWL
WUDG\FML
L
SUDZRZLWR
FL
0DFKLDYHOOL
QLH
SLV]H
GOD
?
NVL
FLD?
XRVDELDM
FHJR
PRQDUFKLF]Q
IRUP
ZÆDG]\
OHF]
GOD
?
N
V
L
F
L
D
Q
R
Z
H
J
R?
LO
SULQFLSH
QXRYR
NWyU\
ZÆDG]\
QLH
RG]LHG]LF]\Æ
OHF]
SR]\VNDÆ
M
?
REF\P
OXE
ZÆDVQ\P
RU
*HP
SU]H]
V]F]
FLH
OXE
RVRELVW
G]LHOQR
ü
?
WDP*H
F]\OL
G\NWDWRUD
SRMDZLDM
FHJR
VL
?
]QLN
G?
:ÆD
FLZLH
W\WXÆ
WHJR
G]LHÆD
,O
SULQFLSH
QLH
SRZLQLHQ
E\
ü
WÆXPDF]RQ\
MDNR
.VL
*
OHF]
:ÆDGFD
D
MHV]F]H
OHSLHM
5]
G]
F\
SRQLHZD*
MHVW
DGHNZDWQ\
GOD
ND*GHM
VSHUVRQLILNRZDQHM
ZÆDG]\
EH]
Z]JO
GX
QD
MHM
W\WXÆ
FKDUDNWHU
L
F]DV
WUZDQLD
:
U]
GDFK
?
NVL
FLD
QRZHJR?
XSDWU\ZDÆ
0DFKLDYHOOL
QDG]LHL
QD
UHDOL]DFM
MHJR
SDWULRW\F]QHJR
FHOX
]MHGQRF]HQLD
:ÆRFK
L
Z\S
G]HQLD
]
,WDOLL
QDMH(G(FyZ
1LHPFyZ
)UDQFX]yZ
+LV]SDQyZ
]D
UHSXEOLND
E\ÆD
GOD
QLHJR
LGHDOQ\P
VWDQHP
GRFHORZ\P
LQQ\PL
VÆRZ\
SU\QF\SDW
WZRU]\
D
UHSXEOLND
XWUZDOD
3RJO
G
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
L*
?
UHSXEOLNL
V
EDUG]LHM
WUZDÆH
RG
PRQDUFKLL
L
GÆX*HM
GRSLVXMH
LP
V]F]
FLH?
5R]ZD*DQLD
QDG
SLHUZV]\P
G]LHVL
FLRNVL
JLHP
KLVWRULL
5]\PX
/LZLXV]D
NV
,,,
U
E\Æ
]UHV]W
Z
MHJR
F]DVDFK
HZHQHPHQWHP
QDZHW
MH*HOL
UHSXEOLNDQL]P
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
XJL
Æ
VL
SU]HG
QDND]DPL
SROLW\F]QHM
NRQLHF]QR
FL
WR
Z
ND*G\P
UD]LH
E\Æ
RQ
]GHF\GRZDQ\P
SU]HFLZQLNLHP
QLHRGSRZLHG]LDOQHM
DXWRNUDFML
?
ZÆDGFD
ERZLHP
NWyUHPX
ZV]\VWNR
ZROQR
SRVW
SXMH
MDN
V]DOHQLHF?
WDP*H
,
7UDG\F\MQD
E\ÆD
QDWRPLDVW
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
NODV\ILNDFMD
JDWXQNRZD
XVWURMyZ
Z\Uy*QLDM
FD
IRUP\
U]
GX
PRQDUFKLF]Q
SULQFLSDWR
DU\VWRNUDW\F]Q
RWWRPDWR
L
GHPRNUDW\F]Q
SRSRODUH
E\Æ
RQ
MHGQDN
ZLDGRP
*H
XVWURMH
GREUH
ÆDWZR
Z\URGQLHM
]
$UW\NXÆ\
3UR
)LGH
5HJH
HW
/HJH
(QF\NORSHGLD
3ROLW\NL
1HNURORJLXP
SUDZLF\
Z
;;,
ZLHNX
/LVW\
.UyOHZVNLH
/HNWXU\
)RUXP
,QQH
VWURQ\
.RQWDNW
.RQWDNW
]
5HGDNFM
3UR
)LGH
5HJH
HW
/HJH
-DN
]RVWD
ü
F]ÆRQNLHP
.OXEX"
6XEVNU\SFMD
7ZyM
DGUHV
H
PDLO
6XEVNU\EXM
3ROHFDP\
KWWS
ZZZ
NRQVHUZDW\]P
SO
HQF\NORSHGLD
SKS"LG
.RQVHUZDW\]P
SO
.OXE
=DFKRZDZF]R
0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\
3UR
ILGH
5HJH
HW
/HJH
6WURQD
]
SRZRGX
SRGRELH
VWZD
GR
IRUP
]Æ\FK
E
G
F\FK
LFK
RGSRZLHGQLNDPL
GODWHJR
]D
Z\M
FLH
]
V\WXDFML
]DSHZQLDM
FH
XVWURMRZL
WUZDÆR
ü
D
SD
VWZX
SRNyM
VSRÆHF]Q\
X]QDZDÆ
?
U]
G
PLHV]DQ\?
UHSXEEOLFD
PLVWD
]
SUHIHUHQFM
GOD
UHSXEOLNL
?
RSW\PDWyZ?
F]\OL
WDNLHM
MDN
LVWQLDÆD
Z
MHJR
URG]LQQHM
)ORUHQFML
6ZRM
SRGVWDZRZ
LQWHQFM
0DFKLDYHOOL
Z\UD]LÆ
GRELWQLH
Z
;9
UR]G]LDOH
.VL
FLD
Z
NWyU\P
SU]HFKRG]L
GR
UR]ZD*DQLD
NZHVWLL
VSRVREX
Z
MDNL
ZÆDGFD
SRZLQLHQ
RGQRVL
ü
VL
GR
SRGGDQ\FK
L
SU]\MDFLyÆ
?
PRLP
]DPLDUHP
MHVW
SLVD
ü
U]HF]\
X*\WHF]QH
GOD
WHJR
NWR
MH
UR]XPLH
SU]HWR
R
ZLHOH
EDUG]LHM
ZÆD
FLZ\P
Z\GDMH
PL
VL
L
ü
]D
SUDZG
U]HF]\ZLVW
]GDU]H
YHULWD
HIIHWWXDOH
GHOOD
FRVD
QL*
]D
MHM
Z\REUD*HQLHP
LPDJLQD]LRQH
GL
HVVD
:LHOX
Z\REUD*DÆR
VRELH
WDNLH
UHSXEOLNL
L
NVL
VWZD
MDNLFK
Z
U]HF]\ZLVWR
FL
DQL
VL
QLH
ZLG]L
DQL
VL
QLH
]QD
ZV]DN
VSRVyE
Z
MDNL
VL
*\MH
MHVW
WDN
Uy*Q\
RG
WHJR
Z
MDNL
VL
*\
ü
SRZLQQR
*H
WHQ
NWR
FKFH
SRVW
SRZD
ü
WDN
MDN
VL
SRZLQQR
SRVW
SRZD
ü
D
QLH
WDN
MDN
VL
SRVW
SXMH
JRWXMH
UDF]HM
VZRM
NO
VN
QL*
]DSHZQLD
SDQRZDQLH
6W
G
F]ÆRZLHN
NWyU\
Z
ND*G\P
VZ\P
SRVW
SNX
]GHF\GRZDQ\
MHVW
SU]HVWU]HJD
ü
]DVDG
GREUD
PXVL
QLHXFKURQQLH
]JLQ
ü
Z
UyG
W\OX
NWyU]\
QLH
V
GREU\PL?
:\QLNDM
FH
]
WHJR
VWZLHUG]HQLD
VPXWQH
NRQVHNZHQFMH
F]HNDM
FH
?
EH]EURQQ\FK
SURURNyZ?
MDN
6DYRQDURO
VWDQRZL
WH*
Z\MD
QLHQLH
]DJDGNRZ\FK
VÆyZ
GHG\NDFML
.VL
FLD
GOD
:DZU]\
FD
0HG\FHXV]D
?
7HJR
G]LHÆD
QLH
XEUDÆHP
L
QLH
]DSHÆQLÆHP
JyUQ\PL
Z\UD*HQLDPL
DQL
V]XPQ\PL
L
NZLHFLVW\PL
VÆRZDPL
DQL
*DGQ
LQQ
SRQ
W
OXE
R]GRE
]HZQ
WU]Q
MDNLPL
SLVDU]H
]Z\F]DMQLH
]GREL
VZH
XWZRU\
ER
FKFLDÆHP
E\
QLF]\P
]JRÆD
QLH
E\ÆR
XSL
NV]RQH
L
E\
Z\Æ
F]QLH
SUDZG]LZR
ü
WUH
FL
WXG]LH*
ZDJD
SU]HGPLRWX
F]\QLÆ\
MH
PLÆ\P?
(VHQFM
P
VWDQRZL
]DOHFHQLD
W\F]
FH
VSRVREX
]GRE\FLD
L
XWU]\PDQLD
ZÆDG]\
Z\ÆR*RQH
Z
UR]G]LDÆDFK
;9
;;,
.VL
FLD
QDOH*
GR
QLFK
SU]HVWURJD
E\
QLH
VLOL
ü
VL
QD
KRMQR
ü
D
IDZRUDPL
V]DIRZD
ü
RVWUR*QLH
L
SRPDÆX
SRFR
D
SRFR
UDGD
E\
U]
G]L
ü
Z]EXG]DM
F
VWUDFK
F]\QL
F
]DUD]HP
ZUD*HQLH
ÆDJRGQR
FL
L
SRER*QR
FL
X]QDQLH
*H
OHSLHM
L*E\
SRGGDQL
EDOL
VL
ZÆDGF\
QL*HOL
JR
OHNFHZD*\OL
]
SRZRGX
MHJR
GREURFL
DF]
]DUD]HP
GREU]H
MHVW
XQLND
ü
SU]\QDMPQLHM
Z]EXG]DQLD
QLHQDZL
FL
MH
OL
QLH
PR*QD
SR]\VND
ü
PLÆR
FL
NRQFHSFMD
GZyFK
NRQLHF]QLH
X]XSHÆQLDM
F\FK
VL
VSRVREyZ
ZDONL
GUDSLH*QHJR
?
OZD?
L
SRGVW
SQHJR
?
OLVD?
JG\*
WU]HED
?
E\
ü
OLVHP
E\
ZLHG]LH
ü
FR
VLGÆD
L
OZHP
E\
SRVWUDFK
EXG]L
ü
X
ZLONyZ?
WDP*H
;9,,,
]DOHFHQLH
E\
Z
UD]LH
NRQLHF]QR
FL
XFLHNQL
FLD
VL
GR
ZLDURÆRPVWZD
SRVW
SRZD
ü
WDN
E\
PyF
REDUF]\
ü
ZLQ
ZURJD
GRSXV]F]HQLH
VWRVRZDQLD
WHUURUX
SUR
SXEOLFR
ERQR
DOH
Z
JUDQLFDFK
UR]V
GNX
U]HF]\ZLVWHM
SRWU]HE\
L
VNDOL
]DJUR*HQLD
MDN
QDMPQLHMV]\P
NRV]WHP
L
Z
PR*OLZLH
QDMNUyWV]\P
F]DVLH
FHORZR
ü
Z\QDMG\ZDQLD
]DZF]DVX
?
NR]ÆD
RILDUQHJR?
GOD
HJ]HNXFML
SRVXQL
ü
QLHSRSXODUQ\FK
E
G(
GOD
]DWDUFLD
QLHSRZRG]H
SRGV\FDQLH
Z]DMHPQHM
QLHQDZL
FL
X
]DQWDJRQL]RZDQ\FK
ZURJyZ
DSUREDWD
GOD
XFLHNDQLD
VL
GR
?
]ER*QHJR
RNUXFLH
VWZD?
L
X*\ZDQLD
]DZV]H
?
UHOLJLL
MDNR
SR]RUX?
WDP*H
;;,
-DNR
*H
?
JPLQ
OLF]\
VL
W\ONR
]
SR]RUDPL?
SROLW\ND
ZLQQD
E\
ü
GREU]H
L
VXJHVW\ZQLH
RGHJUDQ\P
VSHNWDNOHP
?
3RZLQLHQ
SU]HWR
NVL
*
EDUG]R
QDG
W\P
F]XZD
ü
E\
WHPX
NWR
JR
ZLG]L
L
VÆ\V]\
Z\GDZDÆ
VL
FDÆ\
PLÆRVLHUG]LHP
FDÆ\
ZLHUQR
FL
FDÆ\
OXG]NR
FL
FDÆ\
SUDZR
FL
FDÆ\
UHOLJLMQR
FL
6]F]HJyOQLH
SRWU]HEQH
MHVW
DE\
VL
]GDZDÆR
*H
VL
PD
W
RVWDWQL
ZÆD
FLZR
ü
?
WDP*H
;9,,,
5]HF]\ZLVWH
SRVLDGDQLH
FQyW
SU]\QRVL
NVL
FLX
UDF]HM
V]NRG
QDWRPLDVW
ZUD*HQLH
*H
MH
SRVLDGD
SR*\WHN
GODWHJR
PXVL
RQ
E\
ü
ELHJÆ\
Z
V]WXFH
PLVW\ILNDFML
WDN
MDN
SDSLH*
$OHNVDQGHU
9,
%RUJLD
NWyU\
?
QLF
LQQHJR
QLJG\
QLH
F]\QLÆ
MDN
W\ONR
RV]XNLZDÆ
OXG]L
R
QLF]\P
WH*
LQQ\P
QLH
P\
ODÆ?
D
*DGQ\FK
SU]\VL
J
QLH
GRWU]\P\ZDÆ
?
PLPR
WR
RV]XVWZD
XGDZDÆ\
PX
VL
]DZV]H
JG\*
GREU]H
]QDÆ
W
VWURQ
ZLDWD?
WDP*H
’OD
ZÆDGF\
NRQLHF]QH
MHVW
XPLH
ü
?
XSL
NV]D
ü
QDWXU
?
F]\OL
?
E\
ü
GREU\P
NÆDPF
L
REÆXGQLNLHP?
WDP*H
ZLDGRPLH
L
V]F]HU]H
ZÆDGFD
ZLQLHQ
XQLND
ü
?
KD
E\
W\ONR
WDNLFK
ZDG
NWyUH
E\
SR]EDZL
ü
JR
PRJÆ\
SDQRZDQLD?
FR
VL
]D
W\F]\
W\FK
?
NWyUH
PX
W\P
QLH
JUR*
?
WR
Z\VWU]HJD
ü
VL
LFK
PXVL
W\ONR
?
R
W\OH
R
LOH
MHVW
WR
PR*OLZH
OHF]
MH
OL
WR
QLH
MHVW
PR*OLZH
QLH
SRWU]HEXMH
]E\WQLR
QLHSRNRL
ü
VL
QLPL?
WDP*H
;9
8RJyOQLHQLHP
W\FK
V]F]HJyÆRZ\FK
L
SUDNW\F]Q\FK
ZVND]yZHN
MHVW
ERGDM
QDMVÆ\QQLHMV]H
]GDQLH
QDSLVDQH
SU]H]
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
SRFKRG]
FH
]
5R]ZD*D
QDG
SLHUZV]\P
G]LHVL
FLRNVL
JLHP
KLVWRULL
5]\PX
/LZLXV]D
D
XFKRG]
FH
SRZV]HFKQLH
]D
QDMEDUG]LHM
NODURZQ
GHILQLFM
U
D
F
M
L
V
W
D
Q
X
PLPR
L*
0DFKLDYHOOL
QLJG\
WHUPLQX
WHJR
QLH
X*\Æ
?
.LHG\
FKRG]L
ERZLHP
R
RFDOHQLH
RMF]\]Q\
QLH
ZROQR
NLHURZD
ü
VL
W\P
FR
VÆXV]QH
OXE
QLHVÆXV]QH
OLWR
FLZH
OXE
RNUXWQH
FKZDOHEQH
OXE
VURPRWQH
1DG
ZV]\VWNR
LQQH
]ZD*D
ü
QDOH*\
ZWHG\
QD
WR
DE\
]DSHZQL
ü
MHM
SU]HWUZDQLH
L
XUDWRZD
ü
MHM
ZROQR
ü
?
,,,
VN
GLQ
G
WD
P\
O
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
MHVW
UR]ZLQL
FLHP
UyZQLH
VÆ\QQHM
GHZL]\
VWDUR*\WQ\FK
KWWS
ZZZ
NRQVHUZDW\]P
SO
HQF\NORSHGLD
SKS"LG
.RQVHUZDW\]P
SO
.OXE
=DFKRZDZF]R
0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\
3UR
ILGH
5HJH
HW
/HJH
6WURQD
]
5]\PLDQ
VDOXV
5HLSXEOLFDH
VXSUHPD
OH[
HVWR
=DOHFHQLD
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
QDOH*\
UR]SDWU\ZD
ü
SU]\
XZ]JO
GQLHQLX
MHJR
DQWURSRORJLF]QHJR
S
H
V
\
P
L
]
P
X
SRGNUH
OD
RQ
*H
ZLDURÆRPVWZR
V]DOELHUVWZR
SRGVW
S
L
VLÆD
QLH
E\Æ\E\
GREU
UHJXÆ
?
JG\E\
ZV]\VF\
OXG]LH
E\OL
GREU]\?
.VL
*
;9,,,
DOH
WDN
QLH
MHVW
ZLDW
Z\SHÆQLD
?
QLNF]HPQ\
PRWÆRFK?
D
OXG]LH
]
QDWXU\
VNÆRQQL
V
W\ONR
GR
]ÆHJR
L
MH
OL
QDZHW
]GDU]D
VL
*H
SRVW
SXM
GREU]H
WR
W\ONR
]
NRQLHF]QR
FL
7\ONR
SUDZD
F]\QL
OXG]L
GREU\PL
7HQ
NWR
U]
G]L
SD
VWZHP
PXVL
]DWHP
Z\FKRG]L
ü
]
]DÆR*HQLD
*H
OXG]LH
V
(OL
SRGOL
OHQLZL
VÆDEL
L
]HSVXFL
L
QDZHW
U]DGNR
SRWUDIL
E\
ü
]Æ\PL
Z
VSRVyE
EXG]
F\
UHVSHNW
3HV\PL]P
WHQ
QLH
VNÆDQLD
MHGQDN
GR
ELHUQHJR
IDWDOL]PX
OHF]
MHVW
KHURLF]Q\
0DFKLDYHOOL
]DFK
FD
GR
Z\NU]HVDQLD
]
VLHELH
PDNVLPXP
HQHUJLL
NWyUD
MHVW
WR*VDPD
]
F
Q
R
W
YLUWX
RE\ZDWHOVNLHM
G]LHOQR
FL
&KRFLD*
FHQWUDOQH
PLHMVFH
FQRW\
QD
SR]yU
QLH
Z\Uy*QLD
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
RG
P\
OLFLHOL
NODV\F]Q\FK
Z
U]HF]\ZLVWR
FL
SRM
FLH
WR
]PLHQLD
X
QLHJR
]DVDGQLF]R
VHQV
SRQLHZD*
Z\Æ
F]RQD
MHVW
]
QLHJR
QLH]DOH*QD
RG
SROLW\NL
WUH
ü
PRUDOQD
0DNLDZHOLD
VND
YLUWX
WR
UR]XP
SROLW\F]Q\
SDQXM
F\
PLDÆR
QDG
FLHPQ\P
SRVSyOVWZHP
RUD]
QDJLQDM
F\
MHJR
QDURZ\
L
IDQDEHULH
GR
UHDOL]DFML
FHOyZ
VÆX*
F\FK
NRQLHF]QR
FLRP
SROLW\F]Q\P
YLUWX
WZRU]\
QLHRGÆ
F]Q
SDU
]
)
R
U
W
X
Q
ORVHP
ZFKRG]
F
]
QL
Z
DPELZDOHQWQ\
SU]\FL
JDM
FR
RGS\FKDM
F\
]ZL
]HN
TXDVL
PLÆRVQ\
)RUWXQD
ERZLHP
MHVW
NRELHW
NWyU
?
WU]HED
NRQLHF]QLH
EL
ü
L
GU
F]\
ü
DE\
M
SRVL
ü
L
WDF\
NWyU]\
WR
F]\QL
]Z\FL
*DM
ÆDWZLHM
QL*
FL
NWyU]\
SRVW
SXM
RJO
GQLH?
WDP*H
;;9
)RUWXQD
SU]\UyZQ\ZDQD
MHVW
WDN*H
GR
UZ
FHM
U]HNL
NWyUD
MHVW
JUR(QD
OHF]
QLH
ZV]HFKPRFQD
L
]Z\FL
*D
W\ONR
ZWHG\
NLHG\
QLH
QDSRW\ND
RSRUX
]H
VWURQ\
JRWRZHM
M
XMDU]PL
ü
YLUWX
MDN
Z
]QDQ\P
SRU]HNDGOH
ORV
VSU]\MD
]DWHP
PLDÆ\P
]ZÆDV]F]D
PÆRG\P
ER
FL
V
?
EDUG]LHM
]DSDOF]\ZL
L
]
ZL
NV]
]XFKZDÆR
FL
UR]ND]XM
?
WDP*H
]
GUXJLHM
VWURQ\
QDZHW
QDMZL
NV]\
JHQLXV]
QLH
]GRÆD
SU]HFLZVWDZL
ü
VL
WHQGHQFMRP
VZRLFK
F]DVyZ
OD
TXDOLWD
GHL
WHPSL
PR*H
W\ONR
Z\NRU]\VWD
ü
XPLHM
WQLH
VSRVREQR
ü
RFFDVLRQH
NWyU
RQH
QDVWU
F]DM
)DGQD
]
?
QLNF]HPQ\FK?
UDG
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
VDPD
Z
VRELH
QLH
E\ÆD
Z
JUXQFLH
U]HF]\
QRZD
L
ND*G
]
RVREQD
PR*QD
RGQDOH(
ü
Z
PDNV\PDFK
Uy*Q\FK
DXWRUyZ
VWDUR*\WQ\FK
MDN
UyZQLH*
Z
Z\NÆDGDQHM
SU]H]
VFKRODVW\NyZ
UHGQLRZLHF]Q\FK
HW\FH
V\WXDF\MQHM
GRW\F]
FHM
VWDQX
NRQLHF]QR
FL
]ZDQHJR
?
NRQLHF]QR
FL
FHOX?
NWyUD
NDQRQLVWRP
VÆX*\ÆD
]D
X]DVDGQLHQLH
SDSLHVNLHJR
SUDZD
G\VSHQVDFML
RG
UHJXÆ\
RJyOQHM
3RPL
G]\
ILOR]RIDPL
NODV\F]Q\PL
L
WHRORJDPL
NDWROLFNLPL
D
0DFKLDYHOOLP
LVWQLHMH
QDWRPLDVW
NDUG\QDOQD
Uy*QLFD
Z
W\P
*H
GOD
SLHUZV]\FK
RGVW
SVWZR
RG
QRUP\
PRUDOQHM
XVSUDZLHGOLZLRQH
MHVW
W\ONR
Z
REOLF]X
QLHEH]SLHF]H
VWZD
U]HF]\ZLVWHJR
L
MX*
]DLVWQLDÆHJR
D
V\WXDFMH
WR
X]DVDGQLDM
FH
WUDNWRZDQH
V
]DZV]H
MDNR
SU]\SDGNL
DQRUPDOQH
LQG\ZLGXDOQH
L
QLHSRZWDU]DOQH
SRGF]DV
JG\
0DFKLDYHOOL
XZD*D
*H
SRVW
SRZDQLH
WDNLH
MHVW
GRSXV]F]DOQH
MX*
SUHZHQF\MQLH
Z
VDP\P
SU]HZLG\ZDQLX
QLHEH]SLHF]H
VWZD
D
V\WXDFMH
WHJR
URG]DMX
XZD*DÆ
]D
WUZDÆH
WRWH*
]
SRVW
SRZDQLD
ZEUHZ
QRUPLH
F]\QLÆ
QRUP
]DVDG
GOD
DXWRUD
.VL
FLD
SU]HVWU]H
SROLW\NL
MHVW
REV]DUHP
S
H
U
P
D
Q
H
Q
W
Q
H
J
R
V
W
D
Q
X
Z
\
M
W
N
R
Z
H
J
R
&HO
MDNL
VWDZLD
VRELH
L
ZÆDG]\
0DFKLDYHOOL
MHVW
W\ONR
SUDNW\F]Q\
XW\OLWDUQ\
MDN
SRVW
SRZD
ü
E\
]GRE\
ü
ZÆDG]
RUD]
MHM
QLH
VWUDFL
ü
MHJR
PHWRGD
MHVW
HPSLU\F]QD
L
LQGXNF\MQD
DF]
LQGXNFMD
F]
VWR
QDJLQDM
FD
IDNW\
GR
SRJO
GyZ
UR]XPLHQLH
SROLW\NL
XWR*VDPLDM
FH
M
]
ZÆDG]
W\ONR
Z
VHQVLH
SRWHVWDV
VLÆ\
SDQRZDQLD
7\P
VDP\P
P\
O
SROLW\F]QD
P
E\ÆD
U]HF]\ZL
FLH
QRZR
FL
Z
VWRVXQNX
GR
NODV\F]QHM
ILOR]RILL
SROLW\NL
NWyUD
VWDZLDÆD
S\WDQLH
R
QLHXW\OLWDUQ\
L
RELHNW\ZQ\
]
SXQNWX
ZLG]HQLD
VSUDZLHGOLZR
FL
D
FKU]H
FLMD
VND
WDN*H
R
PHWDIL]\F]Q\
FHO
SROLW\NL
L
RGQDMG\ZDÆD
JR
Z
]DSURZDG]DQLX
L
XWU]\P\ZDQLD
ÆDGX
RUGR
RUD]
SRGWU]\PXM
FHM
JR
MHGQR
FL
XQLWDV
Z
SRNRMX
3RQLHZD*
Z
P
UR]XPLHQLH
SROLW\NL
MHVW
WDXWRORJLF]QH
SROLW\ND
WR
ZÆDG]D
D
ZÆDG]D
MHVW
SR
WR
*HE\
U]
G]L
ü
?
URGHN?
U]
G]HQLH
]DPLHQLD
VL
WX
QLHXFKURQQLH
Z
FHO
P
MHVW
SU]HWR
QLH
W\OH
XSRPQLHQLHP
VL
R
D
X
W
R
Q
R
P
L
SROLW\NL
MDNR
G]LHG]LQ\
?
V]WXNL
U]
G]HQLD?
SRVLDGDM
FHM
ZÆDVQH
UHJXÆ\
WDN
MDN
SRVLDGD
MH
HW\ND
F]\
HVWHW\ND
ER
WHM
DXWRU]\
NODV\F]QL
QLH
W\ONR
*H
QLH
SU]HF]\OL
OHF]
ZÆD
QLH
GRFLHNDOL
MHM
]DVDG
OHF]
XVWDQRZLHQLHP
Z
RGHUZDQLX
RG
PHWDIL]\NL
L
WHRORJLL
MHM
D
X
W
R
W
H
O
L
L
VDPRFHORZR
FL
0DNLDZHOLD
VND
PHWRGD
SROLW\F]QHJR
SR]QDQLD
L
G]LDÆDQLD
QLH
SURZDG]L
WDN*H
GR
VWZRU]HQLD
QDXNL
SROLW\F]QHM
SRQLHZD*
]D
ZVND]yZNDPL
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
QLH
VWRL
*DGQD
WHRULD
U]HF]\ZLVWR
FL
QS
RSHUDF\MQR
ü
]DOHFHQLD
DE\
NLHURZD
ü
VL
QLH
W\P
FR
F]\QL
ü
QDOH*\
OHF]
W\P
FR
OXG]LH
F]\QL
QDSUDZG
FKH
VL
ID
MHVW
]
SRZRGX
EH]WURVNR
DWHRUHW\F]QHJR
SRVÆXJLZDQLD
VL
VÆRZDPL
?
SUDZGD?
?
U]HF]\ZLVWR
ü
?
F]\
?
Z\REUD*HQLH?
QLH
W\ONR
F]\VWR
?
WHFKQLF]QD?
DOH
L
RJUDQLF]RQD
ER
VND]XMH
QD
KWWS
ZZZ
NRQVHUZDW\]P
SO
HQF\NORSHGLD
SKS"LG
.RQVHUZDW\]P
SO
.OXE
=DFKRZDZF]R
0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\
3UR
ILGH
5HJH
HW
/HJH
6WURQD
]
VWDW\VW\F]Q
SU]\SDGNRZR
ü
OXG]NLHJR
SRVW
SRZDQLD
L
]
RJURPQ\P
PDUJLQHVHP
EÆ
GX
SR]QDZF]HJR
PDNLDZHOLD
VND
?
SUDZGD
U]HF]\ZLVW\FK
]GDU]H
?
WR
FR
QDMZ\*HM
SU]\F]\QRZR
VNXWNRZH
]ZL
]DQLH
NRQNUHWQ\FK
IDNWyZ
QLH
GDM
FH
SRGVWDZ
GR
V]HUV]\FK
XRJyOQLH
HSLVWHPRORJLF]QLH
MHVW
RQD
EH]ZDUWR
FLRZD
SRQLHZD*
QLH
]DVÆXJXMH
QD
PLDQR
SUDZG\
WR
FR
RERZL
]XMH
W\ONR
Z
NRQWHN
FLH
FL
JOH
]PLHQLDM
F\FK
VL
RNROLF]QR
FL
Z
P
SUDZGD
UR]XPLDQD
NODV\F]QLH
MDNR
]JRGQR
ü
V
GX
]
U]HF]\ZLVWR
FL
D
WDN*H
SUDZGD
RQWRORJLF]QD
]JRGQR
ü
E\WX
RGZ]RURZDQHJR
QD
]LHPL
]
E\WHP
ZLHF]Q\P
QLH
RGJU\ZDM
*DGQHM
UROL
?
SUDZG
?
MHVW
WX
W\ONR
WR
FR
]D
SUDZG
XFKRG]L
5RV]F]HQLH
P
GR
RGNU\FLD
QLH]QDQHM
MDNRE\
ZF]H
QLHM
?
SUDZG\
R
SROLW\FH?
MHVW
Z
WSOLZH
QLH
W\ONR
Z
ZLHWOH
QLHRU\JLQDOQR
FL
SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK
P\
OL
F]\
]DOHFH
DOH
WDN*H
RJUDQLF]H
MHJR
WHRULRSR]QDZF]HJR
Q
R
P
L
Q
D
O
L
]
P
X
NWyU\
ZVNXWHN
QHJDFML
LVWQLHQLD
XQLZHUVDOLyZ
SRM
ü
RJyOQ\FK
VDP
VND]DÆ
VL
QD
QLHPR*QR
ü
SR]QDQLD
F]HJRNROZLHN
FR
Z\NUDF]D
SR]D
VIHU
GR
ZLDGF]HQLD
]P\VÆRZHJR
9HULWD
HIIHWWXDOH
VWDQRZL
UyZQLH*
NDPXIOD*
GOD
]DSR*\F]RQHM
]D
SR
UHGQLFWZHP
V]NRÆ\
SDGHZVNLHM
RG
$ZHUURHVD
NRQFHSFML
?
SRGZyMQHM
SUDZG\?
RGGDQHM
Z
G\VSR]\FM
ZÆDGF\
?
SUDZG\
GOD
PDOXF]NLFK?
F]\OL
X*\WHF]QHJR
SROLW\F]QLH
NÆDPVWZD
L
?
SUDZG\
GOD
P
GUFyZ?
NWyUHM
XGRVW
SQLHQLH
SRVSyOVWZX
PRJÆRE\
RND]D
ü
VL
V]NRGOLZH
GOD
SD
VWZD
2ED
SRZRG\
QLHREHFQR
ü
W
H
O
H
R
O
R
J
L
L
SROLW\NL
RUD]
EUDN
WHRULL
U]HF]\ZLVWR
FL
VSUDZLDM
L*
P
QLH
PR*QD
QD]ZD
ü
ILOR]RIL
SROLW\NL
SU]HGPLRWHP
ILOR]RILL
SROLW\NL
MHVW
ERZLHP
?
F]\QLHQLH?
NWyUHJR
FHO
MHVW
PRUDOQ\
L
SROHJD
QD
RNUH
ODQLX
SR*
GDQHJR
VSRVREX
*\FLD
RVL
JDQHJR
G]L
NL
SROLW\FH
]DLQWHUHVRZDQLD
P
GRW\F]
QDWRPLDVW
G]LDÆDQLD
SRM
WHJR
MDNR
?
URELHQLH?
JG]LH
FHO
F]\QQR
FL
MHVW
PRUDOQLH
QHXWUDOQ\
JG\*
LG]LH
WX
R
SL
NQR
DOER
R
X*\WHF]QR
ü
MHVW
RQ
MHG\QLH
W
H
F
K
Q
L
N
SROLW\NL
XF]
F
GLDJQR]RZDQLD
V\WXDFML
PHWRG
SRVW
SRZDQLD
NDONXODFML
VNXWNyZ
SRGHMPRZDQ\FK
G]LDÆD
F]
VWR
]UHV]W
R
SUREOHPDW\F]QHM
SU]\GDWQR
FL
NWR
]ÆR
OLZLH
]DXZD*\Æ
*H
WUDNWXM
F
G]LHÆD
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
MDNR
LQVWUXNWD*
PR*QD
Z
QDMOHSV]\P
Z\SDGNX
GRM
ü
GR
VWDQRZLVND
SRGSUHIHNWD
P
MHVW
]DWHP
D
P
H
W
D
I
L
]
\
F
]
Q
\
ER
SR]EDZLRQ\
RGQLHVLHQLD
GR
E\WX
SR]D
MHJR
HPSLU\F]Q\PL
SU]HMDZLHQLDPL
-DNR
QDLZQ\
L
XSURV]F]RQ\
QDOH*\
QDWRPLDVW
RNUH
OL
ü
]DU]XW
?
QLHPRUDOQR
FL?
Z
VWRVXQNX
GR
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
6N
GLQ
G
ZLDGRPR
*H
MDNR
F]ÆRZLHN
SU\ZDWQ\
SURZDG]LÆ
RQ
*\FLH
SU]\NÆDGQH
D
MDNR
XU]
GQLN
SD
VWZRZ\
E\Æ
ZU
F]
Z]RUHP
XF]FLZR
FL
L
VXPLHQQR
FL
*DHWDQR
0RVFD
SRGNUH
OD
*H
?
SRVLDGDÆ
RQ
WH*
Z
Z\VRNLP
VWRSQLX
FQRW
NWyU
QD]\ZDP\
XF]FLZR
FL
]DZRGRZ
D
NWyUD
SROHJD
QD
SRGDQLX
F]\WHOQLNRZL
VZHM
P\
OL
EH]
Z]JO
GX
QD
SRZRG]HQLH
OXE
QLHSRZRG]HQLH
NVL
*NL
EH]
Z]JO
GX
WDN*H
QD
NRU]\
FL
OXE
QLHEH]SLHF]H
VWZD
Z\QLNDM
FH
VW
G
GOD
DXWRUD?
+LVWRULD
GRNWU\Q
SROLW\F]Q\FK
RG
VWDUR*\WQR
FL
GR
QDV]\FK
F]DVyZ
:DUV]DZD
>
@
1LH
E\Æ
DQL
NDULHURZLF]HP
ER
JG\E\
QLP
E\Æ
WR
SU]\
VZRLFK
]GROQR
FLDFK
]DV]HGÆE\
QD
SHZQR
Z\*HM
DQL
RV]XVWHP
ER
JG\E\
QLP
E\Æ
WR
QLH
QDSLVDÆE\
NVL
*NL
XF]
FHM
V]WXNL
ZSURZDG]DQLD
Z
EÆ
G
SUDZG]LZL
RV]X
FL
QLH
XMDZQLDM
VZRLFK
WDMHPQLF
7\ONR
SR]RUQ\P
SDUDGRNVHP
MDNR
*H
GRW\F]\
F]ÆRZLHND
?
NWyUHJR
QD]ZLVNR
VWDÆR
VL
V\QRQLPHP
GZXOLFRZR
FL
L
V]DOELHUVWZD?
MHVW
WH*
VSRVWU]H*HQLH
*H
0DFKLDYHOOL
?
MDN
ZL
NV]R
ü
W\FK
NWyU\FK
P\
O
NV]WDÆWRZDÆD
VL
QD
NVL
*NDFK
MHVW
LGHDOLVW
D
MDN
ZV]\VF\
LGHDOL
FL
E\ZD
QDLZQ\?
WDP*H
$XWRU
.VL
FLD
QLH
E\Æ
HW\F]Q\P
UHODW\ZLVW
QLH
]DSU]HF]DÆ
LVWQLHQLX
RELHNW\ZQHJR
GREUD
L
]ÆD
DQL
QLH
SUyERZDÆ
]DFLHUD
ü
JUDQLF\
SRPL
G]\
QLPL
MDN
UyZQLH*
X]DOH*QLD
ü
ZDUWR
FLRZDQLD
F]\QX
RG
?
SXQNWyZ
ZLG]HQLD?
UR]PDLW\FK
LGHRORJLL
?
RULHQWDFML?
F]\
LQWHUHVyZ
SDUW\NXODUQ\FK
Z
W\P
VHQVLH
QLH
E\Æ
QDZHW
?
QRZRF]HVQ\?
=EURGQL
QD]\ZDÆ
]EURGQL
SU]HPRF
SU]HPRF
]GUDG
]GUDG
ZLDURÆRPVWZR
ZLDURÆRPVWZHP
SU]\]QDZDÆ
WR
QDZHW
MHJR
WDN
VXURZ\
NU\W\N
MDN
-DFTXHV
0DULWDLQ
GRGDM
F
*H
0DFKWSROLWLN
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
QLH
SUHWHQGXMH
GR
WHJR
DE\
%yJ
E\Æ
SR
MHM
VWURQLH
0RUDO
3KLORVRSK\
/RQGRQ
’RNÆDGQH
EDGDQLD
Z\ND]DÆ\
*H
WDNLFK
VÆyZ
MDN
?
GREU\?
EXRQR
?
]Æ\?
FDWWLYR
?
XF]FLZ\?
RQHVWR
?
QLHOXG]NL?
LQXPDQR
X*\ZD
0DFKLDYHOOL
GRNÆDGQLH
Z
WDNLP
]QDF]HQLX
Z
MDNLP
X*\ZDQR
LFK
Z
M
]\NX
SRWRF]Q\P
]D
MHJR
*\FLD
L
Z
MDNLP
X*\ZD
VL
LFK
QDGDO
7ZLHUG]LÆ
QDWRPLDVW
*H
Z
G]LDÆDQLX
SROLW\F]Q\P
SRVW
SNL
WDNLH
SU]\QRV]
QLH
SU]HVWDM
F
E\
ü
PRUDOQLH
XMHPQ\PL
]D]Z\F]DM
NRU]\
ü
SRGF]DV
JG\
ZDUXQNRZDQH
VNUXSXÆDPL
HW\F]Q\PL
SRZVWU]\P\ZDQLH
VL
RG
QLFK
QD
RJyÆ
SURZDG]L
GR
]JXE\
:EUHZ
SRPyZLHQLRP
QDMEDUG]LHM
]DSDOF]\Z\FK
DQW\PLDNLDZHOLVWyZ
DOER
SRFKZDÆRP
QLHSURV]RQ\FK
DSRORJHWyZ
0DFKLDYHOOL
QLJG\
QLH
JÆRVLÆ
MDNRE\
F]\Q\
QLHPRUDOQH
L
]EURGQLF]H
QDOH*DÆR
SRSHÆQLD
ü
D
W\P
EDUG]LHM
DE\
Z
LFK
SRSHÆQLDQLX
]QDMGRZD
ü
VDG\VW\F]QH
XSRGREDQLH
SU]HFLZQLH
]
SXQNWX
ZLG]HQLD
P
?
EH]LQWHUHVRZQL?
VDG\
FL
SRNURMX
.DOLJXOL
F]\
7DPHUODQD
V
QDMJRUV]\PL
]
PR*OLZ\FK
KWWS
ZZZ
NRQVHUZDW\]P
SO
HQF\NORSHGLD
SKS"LG
.RQVHUZDW\]P
SO
.OXE
=DFKRZDZF]R
0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\
3UR
ILGH
5HJH
HW
/HJH
6WURQD
]
ZÆDGFyZ
DOERZLHP
WHQ
NWR
JXVWXMH
Z
]EURGQL
Z]EXG]D
SRZV]HFKQ\
ZVWU
W
ZL
F
ZFDOH
QLH
MHVW
VNXWHF]Q\
L
QLH
E
G]LH
]GROQ\
RFDOL
ü
SD
VWZD
?
’]LND
VURJR
ü
L
QLHOXG]NR
ü
Z
SRÆ
F]HQLX
]
QLH]OLF]RQ\PL
]EURGQLDPL?
.VL
*
9,,,
W\UDQD
6\UDNX]
$JDWRNOHVD
SU]\QLRVÆ\
PX
ZSUDZG]LH
VXNFHV
DOH
RNU\Æ\
MHJR
LPL
WDN
KD
E
*H
QLH
ZV]HGÆ
RQ
GR
SDQWHRQX
ERKDWHUyZ
OXG]NR
FL
Z
SU]HFLZLH
VWZLH
GR
7H]HXV]D
5RPXOXVD
0RM*HV]D
L
&\UXVD
NWyU]\
ZSUDZG]LH
WH*
SRSHÆQLDOL
F]\Q\
NUZDZH
DOH
W\ONR
R
W\OH
R
LOH
E\ÆR
WR
NRQLHF]QH
L
NRU]\VWQH
GOD
RE\ZDWHOL
1D
QHJDW\ZQ\FK
SU]\NÆDGDFK
3L]\VWUDWD
’LRQL]MRVD
L
&H]DUD
0DFKLDYHOOL
GRZRG]L
WDN*H
]JXEQR
FL
F]\VWHM
*
G]\
ZÆDG]\
1LH
?
VDG\]P?
OHF]
EH]QDPL
WQ\
SUDJPDW\]P
DOH
UyZQLH*
FK
ü
PLQLPDOL]DFML
L
?
]ZLQL
FLD?
VSLUDOL
MX*
]DLVWQLDÆHM
SU]HPRF\
SU]\
ZLHFD
GRNRQDQHPX
SU]H]
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
UR]Uy*QLHQLX
SRPL
G]\
?
GREU\P?
OXE
?
]Æ\P?
SRVÆXJLZDQLHP
VL
RNUXFLH
VWZHP
NWyUH
SROHJD
QD
W\P
*H
?
GREU]H
X*\W\PL
PRJ
QD]\ZD
ü
VL
WH
MH*HOL
R
]ÆHP
ZROQR
SRZLHG]LH
ü
*H
MHVW
GREUHP
NWyUH
SRSHÆQLD
VL
UD]
MHGHQ
]
NRQLHF]QR
FL
GOD
XEH]SLHF]HQLD
VL
QLH
SRZWDU]D
VL
LFK
Sy(QLHM
D
NWyUH
QDGWR
SU]\QRV]
PR*OLZLH
QDMZL
NV]\
SR*\WHN
SRGGDQ\P?
QDWRPLDVW
?
(OH
X*\W\PL
V
WDNLH
NWyUH
FKR
ü
E\
]
SRF]
WNX
QLHOLF]QH
]
F]DVHP
PQR*
VL
]DPLDVW
U]HGQLH
ü
?
WDP*H
5]
G\
EH]P\
OQLH
RNUXWQH
L
SRJDUGOLZLH
GHSF]
FH
XF]XFLD
OXG]L
ZFDOH
QLH
V
GOD
ZÆDGF\
EH]SLHF]QH
GREUH
U]
G]HQLH
SROHJD
SU]HFLH*
QD
VNXWHF]Q\P
Z\WZDU]DQLX
SU]H
ZLDGF]HQLD
*H
ZÆDGFD
F]\QL
GREU]H
’ODWHJR
?
GREU]H
XU]
G]RQH
SD
VWZD
L
P
GU]\
NVL
*
WD
VWDUDOL
VL
]DZV]H
EDUG]R
SLOQLH
R
WR
E\
PR*Q\FK
QLH
SU]\SURZDG]D
ü
GR
UR]SDF]\
D
GRJDG]D
ü
OXGRZL
L
]DGRZROL
ü
JR
JG\*
WR
MHVW
MHGQR
]
QDMZD*QLHMV]\FK
]DGD
NVL
FLD?
WDP*H
;,;
0LQLPXP
WHJR
FR
XF]\QL
ü
PR*H
UR]WURSQ\
NVL
*
DE\
QLH
E\
ü
]QLHQDZLG]RQ\P
MHVW
SRZ
FL
JQL
FLH
VL
?
RG
PLHQLD
VZRLFK
RE\ZDWHOL
L
SRGGDQ\FK
L
RG
LFK
QLHZLDVW?
DOERZLHP
?
OXG]LH
SU
G]HM
SXV]F]DM
Z
QLHSDPL
ü
PLHU
ü
RMFD
QL*
VWUDW
RMFRZL]Q\?
WDP*H
;9,,
7HJR
URG]DMX
UDG\
QLH
W\ONR
*H
QLH
V
QLHPRUDOQH
DOH
QDZHW
QD
WOH
]DVWDQHM
SUDNW\NL
PR*QD
MH
WUDNWRZD
ü
MDNR
SUyE
SRGGDQLD
ZÆDGFyZ
QLHEÆDK\P
RJUDQLF]HQLRP
-HGQDN
ZL
NV]H
]QDF]HQLH
QL*
GR
SUREOHPDW\F]QHM
D
SULRUL
PRUDOQR
FL
ZÆDGFyZ
SU]\ZL
]\ZDÆ
0DFKLDYHOOL
GR
]ZL
]DQLD
U]
G]
F\FK
SU]HSLVDPL
SUDZD
Z
F]\P
XSDWU\ZDÆ
OHSV]HM
?
U
NRMPL
EH]SLHF]H
VWZD
GOD
ZV]\VWNLFK
LFK
SRGGDQ\FK?
5R]ZD*DQLD
,
GDM
F
]D
SR]\W\ZQ\
Z]yU
.UyOHVWZR
)UDQFML
-HG\QH
F]HJR
0DFKLDYHOOL
U]HF]\ZL
FLH
SUDJQLH
GRZLH
ü
WR
WZLHUG]HQLH
L*
Z
SROLW\FH
QLH
GD
VL
XQLNQ
ü
F]\QyZ
Z
*\FLX
SU\ZDWQ\P
XZD*DQ\FK
SRZV]HFKQLH
]D
QLHHW\F]QH
PLPR
WR
MHGQDN
SROLW\ND
RERZL
]XMH
SRF]XFLH
PLDU\
L
JUDQLF
0DFKLDYHOOL
WHG\
QLH
MHVW
?
QLHPRUDOQ\?
OHF]
?
D
P
R
U
D
O
Q
\?
QLH
SU]HF]\
HW\FH
RELHNW\ZQHM
W\ONR
]DZLHV]D
MHM
RERZL
]\ZDQLH
Z
G]LHG]LQLH
SROLW\NL
Z
LPL
Z\PRJyZ
SROLW\F]QHM
?
NRQLHF]QR
FL?
NWyUD
]QD
W\ONR
MHGQ
UHJXÆ
]DVDG
NRU]\
FL
L
Z]DMHPQR
FL
?
2Wy*
P
GU\
SDQ
QLH
PR*H
DQL
SRZLQLHQ
GRWU]\P\ZD
ü
ZLDU\
MH*HOL
WDNLH
GRWU]\P\ZDQLH
SU]\QRVL
PX
V]NRG
L
JG\
]QLNQ
Æ\
SU]\F]\Q\
NWyUH
VSRZRGRZDÆ\
MHJR
SU]\U]HF]HQLH?
.VL
*
;9,,,
0
GU\
SROLW\N
QLH
SRZLQLHQ
ZSUDZG]LH
?
SRU]XFD
ü
GREUHJR
JG\
PR*QD?
OHF]
?
PXVL
XPLH
ü
F]\QL
ü
]ÆR
JG\
WU]HED?
WDP*H
-H*HOL
FHFK\
?
OLVD?
L
?
OZD?
]RVWDQ
GREU]H
VNRPELQRZDQH
WR
SROLW\N
R
F]\P
ZLDGF]
SU]\NÆDG\
$JHVLODRVD
7LPROHRQD
.DPLOOXVD
F]\
6F\SLRQD
PR*H
SR]ZROL
ü
VRELH
QD
SUDZR
ü
ÆDJRGQR
ü
OLWR
ü
V]ODFKHWQR
ü
L
ZLHONRGXV]QR
ü
MH
OL
MHGQDN
RNROLF]QR
FL
XNÆDGDM
VL
QLHIRUWXQQLH
WR
QLH
SR]RVWDMH
PX
QLF
LQQHJR
MDN
QD
ODGRZDQLH
)LOLSD
0DFHGR
VNLHJR
+DQQLEDOD
F]\
6HZHUXVD
3RGREQLH
PQLHM
GZX]QDF]Q\
QL*
WR
VL
F]
VWR
Z\ROEU]\PLD
MHVW
VWRVXQHN
0DFKLDYHOOHJR
GR
UHOLJLL
:
W\P
]DNUHVLH
P
QLH
SROHJD
DQL
QD
DWHL]PLH
RVRELVW\P
JG\*
]
QDSLVDQHJR
URN
SU]HG
PLHUFL
WHVWDPHQWX
DXWRUD
.VL
FLD
(VRUWD]LRQH
DOOD
SHQLWHQ]D
Z\QLND
*H
?
SU\ZDWQLH?
E\Æ
RQ
NDWROLNLHP
FKR
ü
QLH
PD
SHZQR
FL
F]\
QLH
MHVW
WR
DSRNU\I
DQL
QD
SU]HGVWDZLHQLX
DOWHUQDW\ZQHJR
VSRVREX
UR]XPLHQLD
?
SROLW\NL
FKU]H
FLMD
VNLHM?
MDN
SUyERZDOL
GRZLH
ü
?
PDNLDZHOL
FL
FKU]H
FLMD
VF\?
OHF]
QD
UDG\NDOQ\P
RGVHSDURZDQLX
SROLW\NL
RG
UHOLJLL
LQWHQFMRQDOQLH
L
LQ
FRQFUHWR
MHVW
WR
VHSDUDFMD
SROLW\NL
RG
UHOLJLL
FKU]H
FLMD
VNLHM
NDWROLFNLHM
F]HJR
ZSURVW
SRGDQ
PRW\ZDFM
MHVW
WR
*H
QDND]\
PRUDOQH
WHM
UHOLJLL
NROLGXM
]H
VNXWHF]QR
FL
SROLW\NL
0DFKLDYHOOL
Z
*DGQ\P
PLHMVFX
QLH
SRGHMPXMH
G\VNXVML
DQL
]
SUDZGDPL
ZLDU\
JÆRV]RQ\PL
SU]H]
.R
FLyÆ
DQL
]
RERZL
]\ZDOQR
FL
L
ZDUWR
FL
FQyW
FKU]H
FLMD
VNLFK
Z
*\FLX
SU\ZDWQ\P
W\ONR
XSRUF]\ZLH
GRZRG]L
LFK
QLHSU]\GDWQR
FL
RE\ZDWHOVNLHM
&KU]H
FLMD
VWZR
MHJR
]GDQLHP
MHVW
VSU]HF]QH
]
HWRVHP
UHSXEOLND
VNLP
SRQLHZD*
XF]
F
OXG]L
PLÆRVLHUG]LD
SRNRU\
L
FLHUSOLZHJR
]QRV]HQLD
NU]\ZG
F]\QL
LFK
LVWRWDPL
VÆDE\PL
L
]GROQ\PL
MHG\QLH
GR
]QRV]HQLD
FLHUSLH
]DPLDVW
LFK
SU]H]Z\FL
*DQLD
DF]
SR
Z\UD*HQLX
SU]\SXV]F]HQLD
*H
WR
KWWS
ZZZ
NRQVHUZDW\]P
SO
HQF\NORSHGLD
SKS"LG
[ Pobierz całość w formacie PDF ]

zanotowane.pl

doc.pisz.pl

pdf.pisz.pl

mement.xlx.pl